Akita vs Belgian Malinois vs Irish Setter Comparison
Quick Verdict
Who wins in each category?
Overall Winner
Akita
5/6
categories
Best for Apartments
Akita
5/5 · Ideal
Easiest Grooming
Akita
2/5 · Low maintenance
Longest Lifespan
🤝 Tie
Easiest to Train
Belgian Malinois
4.5/5 · Easy
Most Active
🤝 Tie
Best for First-Time Owners
🤝 Tie
5/6
83%
Akita
👑 Winner
4/6
67%
Belgian Malinois
3/6
50%
Irish Setter
* This summary is based on data from our database. Always make your final decision based on your individual needs.
Common Names & Aliases
Breed Classification
Size Classification
Weight Statistics
Average Weight
Height
Average Height
Intelligence Rating
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for intelligence rating?
Verdict: Belgian Malinois performs best for intelligence rating, with a rating of 4.5/5, while Irish Setter, scoring lower at 4/5; Akita, scoring lower at 3/5.
Watchdog Rating
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for watchdog rating?
Verdict: There is no clear winner: Akita and Belgian Malinois are tied with the highest rating for watchdog rating (5/5), while Irish Setter, scoring lower at 3/5.
Training Difficulty
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for training difficulty?
Verdict: There is no clear winner: Belgian Malinois and Irish Setter are tied with the highest rating for training difficulty (5/5), while Akita, scoring slightly lower at 4/5.
Territorial Protection
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for territorial protection?
Verdict: Akita performs best for territorial protection, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Belgian Malinois, scoring slightly lower at 4/5; Irish Setter, scoring lower at 2/5.
Price Range
Availability
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed is the most available?
Verdict: There is no clear winner: Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter are tied with the highest availability rating of 5/5.
Personality Traits
Sensitivity Level
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for sensitivity level?
Verdict: Akita performs best for sensitivity level, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Belgian Malinois, scoring slightly lower at 4/5; Irish Setter, scoring slightly lower at 4/5.
Impulse to Wander or Roam
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for impulse to wander or roam?
Verdict: Irish Setter performs best for impulse to wander or roam, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Akita, scoring slightly lower at 4/5; Belgian Malinois, scoring slightly lower at 4/5.
Prey Drive
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for prey drive?
Verdict: Irish Setter performs best for prey drive, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Akita, scoring slightly lower at 4/5; Belgian Malinois, scoring lower at 3/5.
Affection Level
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for affection level?
Verdict: There is no clear winner: Akita and Irish Setter are tied with the highest rating for affection level (5/5), while Belgian Malinois, scoring lower at 2/5.
Social Needs
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for social needs?
Verdict: Irish Setter performs best for social needs, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Belgian Malinois, scoring slightly lower at 4/5; Akita, scoring lower at 3/5.
Barking Frequency
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for barking frequency?
Verdict: Belgian Malinois performs best for barking frequency, with a rating of 4/5, while Akita, scoring lower at 1/5; Irish Setter, scoring lower at 1/5.
Playful Nature
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for playful nature?
Verdict: There is no clear winner: Belgian Malinois and Irish Setter are tied with the highest rating for playful nature (5/5), while Akita, scoring lower at 3/5.
Apartment Adaptability
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for apartment adaptability?
Verdict: Akita performs best for apartment adaptability, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Belgian Malinois, scoring lower at 3/5; Irish Setter, scoring lower at 1/5.
Lifestyle Adaptability
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for lifestyle adaptability?
Verdict: There is no clear winner: Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter are tied with the highest rating for lifestyle adaptability (5/5).
Alone Time Tolerance
Bite Risk Assessment
Mouthing Tendency
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for mouthing tendency?
Verdict: Irish Setter performs best for mouthing tendency, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Akita, scoring lower at 3/5; Belgian Malinois, scoring lower at 3/5.
Bite Strength Rating
Average Lifespan
Climate Tolerance
Health Concerns
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for health concerns?
Verdict: There is no clear winner: Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter are tied with the highest rating for health concerns (3/5).
Health Problems
Vet Care Frequency
Energy Rating
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for energy rating?
Verdict: There is no clear winner: Belgian Malinois and Irish Setter are tied with the highest rating for energy rating (5/5), while Akita, scoring slightly lower at 4/5.
Sleeping Need
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for sleeping need?
Verdict: Akita performs best for sleeping need, with a rating of 2/5, while Belgian Malinois, scoring slightly lower at 1/5; Irish Setter, scoring slightly lower at 1/5.
Activity Requirement / Exercise Need
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for activity requirement / exercise need?
Verdict: There is no clear winner: Belgian Malinois and Irish Setter are tied with the highest rating for activity requirement / exercise need (5/5), while Akita, scoring slightly lower at 4/5.
Obesity Tendency
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for obesity tendency?
Verdict: Akita performs best for obesity tendency, with a rating of 4/5, while Irish Setter, scoring slightly lower at 3/5; Belgian Malinois, scoring lower at 2/5.
Food Consumption
Allergy Friendliness
Coat Colors
Grooming Requirements
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for grooming requirements?
Verdict: Irish Setter performs best for grooming requirements, with a rating of 4/5, while Belgian Malinois, scoring slightly lower at 3/5; Akita, scoring lower at 2/5.
Shedding Level
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for shedding level?
Verdict: Akita performs best for shedding level, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Belgian Malinois, scoring lower at 3/5; Irish Setter, scoring lower at 3/5.
Drooling Tendency
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for drooling tendency?
Verdict: Akita performs best for drooling tendency, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Irish Setter, scoring lower at 2/5; Belgian Malinois, scoring lower at 1/5.
Stinkiness Rating
Coat Characteristics
Bathing Needs
Cat Friendly
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for cat friendly?
Verdict: Irish Setter performs best for cat friendly, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Akita, scoring lower at 3/5; Belgian Malinois, scoring lower at 3/5.
Child Compatibility
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for child compatibility?
Verdict: Irish Setter performs best for child compatibility, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Akita, scoring slightly lower at 4/5; Belgian Malinois, scoring slightly lower at 4/5.
Dog Friendly
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for dog friendly?
Verdict: Irish Setter performs best for dog friendly, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Akita, scoring lower at 3/5; Belgian Malinois, scoring lower at 3/5.
Stranger Friendly
Between Akita, Belgian Malinois, and Irish Setter, which breed scores best for stranger friendly?
Verdict: Irish Setter performs best for stranger friendly, with a perfect score of 5/5, while Akita, scoring lower at 2/5; Belgian Malinois, scoring lower at 2/5.
Office Friendly
Senior Citizens Friendly
Pet Compatibility
Good For First Time Owners
Service Dog Capability
Therapy Work Suitability
Scent Detection Ability
Search & Rescue Potential
Maritime Work Ability
Draft Work Capability
Military Service Background
Puppy Litter Size
Pregnancy Duration
Breeding Frequency
AKC Classification
FCI Classification
Kennel Club Recognition
Basic Info
Japan
Belgium
IrelandPopular Dog Compares
American Staffordshire Terrier vs Bull Terrier vs English Cocker Spaniel
Dachshund vs American Staffordshire Terrier
Maremma Shepherd vs Great Pyrenees
Rampur Greyhound vs Caravan Hound vs Rajapalayam dog
Bichon Frise vs Aussiedoodle
Labrador Retriever vs Greater Swiss Mountain Dog
Australian Shepherd vs Black Mouth Cur vs Golden Retriever
Australian Shepherd vs Black Mouth Cur vs Golden Retriever
Croatian Sheepdog vs Pyrenean Shepherd vs Anatolian Pyrenees
Irish Terrier vs Parson Russell Terrier
German Shepherd vs Golden Retriever
Maltipoo vs Toy Poodle
Border Terrier vs Lakeland Terrier
Czechoslovakian Wolfdog vs Sprocker Spaniel
Czechoslovakian Wolfdog vs Siberian Husky